REVIEW: BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL follows Kenny, Frankie, and Ray as they navigate New York City from the 1960s to the 1980s. The novel charts the evolving ambitions and material pursuits of its protagonists. The interconnected narratives of Kenny, Frankie, and Ray illuminate significant social issues and personal challenges. Kenny’s participation in civil rights activism—shaped by the philosophies of Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X—underscores the nuanced realities of idealism amid adversity. Frankie’s progression from Harlem’s criminal milieu to a position of influence in urban commerce is portrayed with intellectual rigor and moral complexity. Ray’s pursuit of a medical career, complicated by personal obstacles, offers a compelling depiction of individual struggle.
Set against a vividly portrayed urban backdrop, the story captures friendship and social change through detailed character development, historical authenticity and emotional resonance. The Upper West Side becomes central to their evolving relationships, making this novel a compelling account of growth, dreams, and the bonds formed amidst cultural transformation.
BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL is presented as a coming-of-age narrative that follows the principal characters' search for identity. Nevertheless, I found Justine's personal journey—Kenny's mother—to be equally compelling. The novel offers as much insight into her experiences as those of the other protagonists. From her early exploitation by affluent individuals to her evolution into a devoted and protective mother who continuously prioritised her son's well-being above her own, Justine's story is particularly resonant. Additionally, her unique connection with Frankie’s Uncle Francis remained memorable long after finishing the book.
Despite the novel’s strengths, I was left curious about Kenny’s twin and his story. Although this omission did not detract significantly from the novel's emotional depth, it did leave me wanting further closure. BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL represents a valuable contribution to the growing body of literature exploring African American experiences and history. I recommend this work to enthusiasts of historical fiction; admirers of Ms. Alers will undoubtedly appreciate it.
NB: This review pertains to the audio edition. The narrator, William Anthony Sebastian Rose II, skillfully conveys both the richness and emotional nuance of the narrative.
18th 2026 | romcol@caribsurf.com
Set against a vividly portrayed urban backdrop, the story captures friendship and social change through detailed character development, historical authenticity and emotional resonance. The Upper West Side becomes central to their evolving relationships, making this novel a compelling account of growth, dreams, and the bonds formed amidst cultural transformation.
BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL is presented as a coming-of-age narrative that follows the principal characters' search for identity. Nevertheless, I found Justine's personal journey—Kenny's mother—to be equally compelling. The novel offers as much insight into her experiences as those of the other protagonists. From her early exploitation by affluent individuals to her evolution into a devoted and protective mother who continuously prioritised her son's well-being above her own, Justine's story is particularly resonant. Additionally, her unique connection with Frankie’s Uncle Francis remained memorable long after finishing the book.
Despite the novel’s strengths, I was left curious about Kenny’s twin and his story. Although this omission did not detract significantly from the novel's emotional depth, it did leave me wanting further closure. BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL represents a valuable contribution to the growing body of literature exploring African American experiences and history. I recommend this work to enthusiasts of historical fiction; admirers of Ms. Alers will undoubtedly appreciate it.
NB: This review pertains to the audio edition. The narrator, William Anthony Sebastian Rose II, skillfully conveys both the richness and emotional nuance of the narrative.
18th 2026 | romcol@caribsurf.com
